The idea of selling products as a service is booming. Instead of a one-time sale, companies want ongoing relationships with customers for predictable, recurring revenue. Think of Rolls-Royce charging for “hours of power” from its jet engines, not the engines themselves.
However, the reality is harsh: most subscription services fail, often within the first year. These failures aren’t bad luck; they follow a predictable pattern. It starts with a bad idea, which leads to flawed pricing, creating operational nightmares, and finally resulting in a poor customer experience that drives users away.
Here’s a breakdown of the four fatal flaws and how to avoid them.
1. The Value Proposition is Broken
The most common reason for failure is that the service doesn’t offer real, sustained value.
- Solving a Problem That Doesn’t Exist: Many companies create over-engineered gadgets for simple tasks. Juicero built a $400 Wi-Fi-connected juicer, only for customers to discover its pre-packaged juice packs could be squeezed by hand just as effectively. The expensive machine was useless.
- Being a Copycat: In a crowded market, being just another “subscription box” isn’t enough. Loot Crate, a box for geek merchandise, initially succeeded on novelty but failed when quality dropped and items became repetitive. The initial excitement wore off, revealing a service with no unique long-term value.
- Misunderstanding the Customer: A great product can fail if it targets the wrong people. Quibi, a streaming service for short, mobile-only videos, raised $1.75 billion and shut down in six months. It charged for content in a world where superior, free, and shareable alternatives like TikTok and YouTube already dominated.
2. The Price is Wrong
A service with a good idea can still be doomed by bad pricing.
- Pricing Based on Cost, Not Value: Prices should be based on the value you provide the customer, not your internal costs. A price that doesn’t align with the customer’s success will feel unfair and won’t work.
- Confusing Tiers and Generous Free Plans: Pricing plans can backfire. If your free plan is too generous, users have no reason to upgrade. If your paid tiers are a confusing list of minor features, potential customers get overwhelmed and don’t buy.
- The Freemium Trap: Offering a free version is a popular way to attract users, but if you can’t convert enough of them to paying customers (typically only 2-5% do), the cost of supporting all the free users will sink your business.
3. Operations Are an Afterthought
For companies offering physical products, the logistical challenges are often fatally underestimated.
- The “Boomerang Effect” of Returns: In a subscription model, you still own the product. You are responsible for getting it back from customers, cleaning or refurbishing it, and sending it out again. This “reverse logistics” is complex and expensive, and many companies fail to plan for it.
- Complex Inventory Management: You have to manage new products for new subscribers while also tracking products that are in transit, being repaired, or waiting to be redeployed. Mismanaging this leads to stockouts (frustrating new customers) or overstocking (tying up cash in idle products).
- The Unseen Costs of Service: Your responsibility for the product never ends. Unlike a one-time sale with a limited warranty, you must cover all maintenance and repairs for as long as the subscription is active. Many companies fail to price these long-term costs into their subscription, leading to shrinking profits over time.
4. The Customer Relationship is Neglected
A subscription is a long-term relationship. Failure to nurture it guarantees customers will leave.
- A Poor First Impression: The first few days are critical. If the setup or onboarding process is confusing, you’ll lose customers before they even have a chance to experience the value of your service.
- Failing to Build a Community: A product can be copied, but a strong community is a unique asset that builds loyalty. Services that treat subscribers like a faceless audience rather than a community make it easy for those subscribers to leave for a competitor.
- Ignoring Customer Churn: Losing customers (churn) is the biggest threat to a subscription business. Successful companies work hard to keep users by offering flexible options (like pausing a subscription instead of canceling), automatically handling failed payments, and learning from exit surveys to fix problems.
Conclusion: How to Build a Service That Lasts
To succeed, a subscription business must be built on four strategic pillars. The difference between failure and success is clear:
| Strategic Pillar | Hall of Shame (Juicero, Loot Crate, Quibi) | Hall of Fame (Xerox, Philips, Rent the Runway) |
| Value Proposition | Over-engineered product solving a non-existent problem. | Outcome-focused service that solves a real customer problem. |
| Economic Model | Price disconnected from the actual value delivered. | Pricing is aligned with the quantifiable value customers receive. |
| Operations | No plan for returns, refurbishment, or long-term service costs. | Full product lifecycle management is core to the business model. |
| Customer Relationship | Transactional view of the customer; no community building. | Community-centric relationship that fosters loyalty and retention. |
Exporteren naar Spreadsheets
By focusing on delivering real value, pricing it correctly, mastering the product lifecycle, and continuously earning customer loyalty, a subscription service can achieve lasting success.
